ZDNet, TechCrunch, ReadWriteWeb; They’ve got it wrong

RIA-Confused

Illustration by Brajeshwar

Rich Internet ApplicationsHow some high profile sites got it all wrong!


I was willing to brush it aside as another harmless mistake by some high profile sites, “we all make mistakes”. However, Mrinal’s second tweet (Mrinal’s articles are here and here) got me thinking and wanted to bring forth some clarifications for the Rich Internet Applications (RIA) realm.

ZDNet

Recently, Mary Jo Foley at ZDNet wrote an article — Microsoft Live Mesh to get more competition from Sun. While talking about JavaOne where Sun unveils their future cloud-computing platform — Hydrazine — which will be in direct competition with similar offerings from Microsoft, Google, Amazon and others, she wrote

ZDNet's wrong interpretation on JavaFX, Adobe AIR and Microsoft Silverlight

“Robert Brewin, Sun Chief Technology Officer and Distinguished Engineer, described Hydrazine as a combination of Amazon’s Elastic Cloud, Microsoft’s Live Mesh and Google Analytics all rolled into one. It’s a platform that Sun is building on top of JavaFX.”

From the article, it is definitely clear that Hydrazine is a server side solution and JavaFX is a client side solution. So, how can Hydrazine be built “on top” of JavaFX?

“JavaFX, which is Sun’s rough equivalent to Adobe AIR and Microsoft’s Silverlight.”

Wrong Again!

  • Microsoft Silverlight and Adobe AIR are NOT equivalent.
  • Microsoft Silverlight is equivalent to Flash Player + the Flex framework.
  • Sun JavaFX is equivalent to Adobe Flash Player + Flex Framework + Adobe AIR + Adobe Mobile.

Further down in the article, she has written

“Sun also is working on JavaFX Script, a new scripting language that will do for Java developers what FlexBuilder and Expression Blend are for Adobe and Microsoft developers, respectively.”

This is Blasphemy,

  • JavaFX Script is a programming language like Adobe’s ActionScript and MXML and is similar to Microsoft’s XAML and their CLR language.
  • Adobe’s FlexBuilder is an Integrated Development Environment like Microsoft’s Visual Studio or Sun’s NetBeans.
  • Microsoft’s Expression Blend is an RIA design tool which is equivalent to Adobe’s Thermo.

TechCrunch

Duncan Riley of TechCrunch wrote about — Adobe AIR Vs Microsoft Silverlight — which I believed is wrong right from the title. It could have been Adobe Flash Player vs Microsoft Silverlight!

Techcrunch's wrong interpretation on comparing Adobe AIR to Microsoft Silverlight

Here, Duncan wrote,

“There’s no arguing that AIR is highly capable, but so is Microsoft’s Silverlight.”

Well, to put things in a simple way — Adobe AIR is the platform independent Desktop Client with built-in Flash Player. It would have been way better to do a comparison of Adobe Flash Player and Microsoft Silverlight and not Adobe AIR with Microsoft Silverlight.

ReadWriteWeb

Bernard Lunn of ReadWriteWeb wrote about MetaASO: A Bootstrapped P2P Startup From India.

ReadWriteWeb's thinks they cannot run Silverlight because they're on Macs

“MetaASO stumbled at the first hurdle for me, which was that you need Silverlight and that means a PC (I use a Mac).”

How cool! Guys, they’re on Macs and no PCs. But, Silverlight can run on a Mac. Silverlight is a browser plugin just like Flash Player and runs on both PC and Mac.

Silverlight is a cross operating system, cross browser plugin which is very similar to Adobe’s Flash Player. It has a subset of abilities of the .NET Runtime. The term Silverlight also includes the web application library built on top of the runtime and this library is very similar to Adobe’s Flex Framework. Microsoft’s .NET runtime is a Windows only desktop runtime. Some version of it is included in most recent version of Windows. It allows you to run Windows desktop applications.

Well, these are the facts churned out by the top profile sites, rendering the prospects of the future Rich Internet Applications, eerr, rather bleak! Or do we really care?

  • Brajeshwar,

    Thanks for spreading the word further, i had been ignoring this confusion for a while too but when things got too frequent I decided to write about it, hopefully we can reach at least a small percentage on the thousands these posts would have confused.

    That said, i cant say I agree with the jab at Americans .. I'm sure I can find several Indians in the technology world who dont understand RIAs either

  • Brajeshwar,

    Thanks for spreading the word further, i had been ignoring this confusion for a while too but when things got too frequent I decided to write about it, hopefully we can reach at least a small percentage on the thousands these posts would have confused.

    That said, i cant say I agree with the jab at Americans .. I'm sure I can find several Indians in the technology world who dont understand RIAs either

  • They're all a bunch of competitive misinformed fanboy idiots. :/ I really hate it when high profile sites churn out lies.

  • They're all a bunch of competitive misinformed fanboy idiots. :/ I really hate it when high profile sites churn out lies.

  • Nothing American about it but that Miss Carolina's speech came to mind, so I decided to tuck her speech in there with some RIA-lingua!

  • Nothing American about it but that Miss Carolina's speech came to mind, so I decided to tuck her speech in there with some RIA-lingua!

  • Pingback: Java Programming News » Blog Archive » Rich Internet Application Misconceptions - JavaProNews.com()

  • Pingback: Peter Elst » Adobe AIR versus Microsoft Silverlight()